- U.K. Health Secretary Wes Streeting criticized the NHS for promoting "misguided approaches" to equality, including "anti-whiteness," at a World Cancer Day event.
- Streeting highlighted the tension between addressing genuine inequalities and the perception that DEI policies have become vehicles for discrimination against certain groups, particularly white working-class communities.
- The Health Secretary emphasized the NHS's legacy of inclusivity while pointing out persistent racial inequalities, such as higher cancer and childbirth mortality rates among Black men and women compared to white counterparts.
- Streeting’s comments reflect a broader global debate over DEI initiatives, with critics arguing that such programs often prioritize identity politics over merit and fairness, and some governments seeking to scale back these programs.
- Streeting called for a more balanced and evidence-based approach to DEI, emphasizing the need for equality to apply to everyone and focusing on measurable outcomes over ideological posturing.
In a striking admission that has reignited debates over the role of diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) initiatives in public institutions, U.K. Health Secretary Wes Streeting has criticized the National Health Service (NHS) for promoting “misguided approaches” to equality, including instances of “anti-whiteness.” Speaking at a Macmillan Cancer Support event on World Cancer Day, Streeting acknowledged the "need" for DEI policies but warned that ideological excesses are undermining their credibility and effectiveness.
The controversy comes at a time when DEI programs are under intense scrutiny globally, with critics arguing that such initiatives often prioritize identity politics over merit and fairness. Streeting’s comments highlight a growing tension between addressing genuine inequalities and the perception that DEI policies have become vehicles for discrimination against certain groups, particularly white working-class communities.
“Anti-whiteness” and the erosion of trust
Streeting’s most explosive revelation was his reference to an NHS staff member who openly promoted “anti-whiteness” as part of their professional practice. The Health Secretary recounted: “There was one member of NHS staff who was merrily tweeting a job ad online and saying part of her practice was anti-whiteness.” He added, “I just thought: what the hell does that say to the bloke up in Wigan who’s more likely to die earlier than his more affluent white counterparts down in London? We’ve got real issues of inequality that affect white working-class people.”
This incident underscores a broader concern that DEI initiatives, while well-intentioned, have strayed from their original purpose. Instead of fostering unity and addressing systemic disparities, some programs have embraced divisive rhetoric that alienates large segments of the population. Streeting’s frustration reflects a growing backlash against what many see as the weaponization of diversity policies to advance ideological agendas.
Historical context: The NHS and diversity
The NHS has long been a symbol of Britain’s commitment to universal healthcare, founded in 1948 on the principle that medical treatment should be available to all, regardless of race, class, or background. The service has also been shaped by the contributions of immigrants, particularly those who arrived on the Empire Windrush in the same year the NHS was established. Streeting emphasized this legacy, stating, “Empire Windrush, NHS foundation, same year – that generation built the NHS.”
However, the Health Secretary also pointed to persistent racial inequalities within the healthcare system. “Black men are twice as likely to die of prostate cancer than white men; black women three times more likely to die in childbirth than white women,” he noted. These disparities highlight the need for targeted interventions to address specific health outcomes. Yet, Streeting argued that such efforts are being undermined by “ideological hobby horses” that distract from the core mission of achieving equality of outcome.
The broader debate: DEI under scrutiny
Streeting’s comments come amid a global reckoning over the role of DEI initiatives in public and private institutions. In the United States, former President Donald Trump recently signed an executive order aimed at dismantling DEI programs in the federal government, calling them “useless and overpaid.” Similarly, in the U.K., NHS bosses have been accused of ignoring directives to scale back diversity roles, with 35 new EDI positions advertised since Labour took power in July 2024.
Critics argue that these roles, which often come with hefty salaries, divert resources from frontline healthcare services. Steve Barclay, former Tory Health Secretary, had previously ordered NHS chiefs to halt the creation of specialist inclusion roles, but many trusts disregarded his instructions. Streeting has not reversed Barclay’s order but has called for a more evidence-based approach to tackling inequalities.
A call for balance and evidence-based solutions
Streeting’s remarks reflect a broader call for balance in the DEI debate. While acknowledging the need to address racial and socioeconomic disparities, he warned against pitting one group’s needs against another’s. “I was really frustrated just last week to see the government’s commitment to have a men’s health strategy juxtaposed against women’s health, as if by focusing on the inequalities that affect men or the issues that affect men, that somehow we’d be deprioritising women,” he said.
The Health Secretary’s comments suggest a shift toward a more inclusive and pragmatic approach to equality—one that prioritizes measurable outcomes over ideological posturing. “What’s been lost, I think, with some well-meaning but misguided approaches to equality, diversity, inclusion, the clue is in the name – it’s equality; it should be applicable to everyone,” he concluded.
Conclusion: A turning point for DEI?
Wes Streeting’s candid critique of NHS diversity policies marks a potential turning point in the DEI debate. By calling out “anti-whiteness” and other divisive practices, he has highlighted the need for a more balanced and evidence-based approach to tackling inequalities. As the NHS grapples with funding constraints and rising demand for services, the focus must remain on delivering equitable healthcare for all—without succumbing to the pitfalls of ideological extremism.
The challenge now is to ensure that DEI initiatives serve their intended purpose: fostering fairness and inclusion, rather than perpetuating division. As Streeting aptly put it, “We’ve got to take a much better approach to this issue.” The future of the NHS—and the trust of the public it serves—depends on it.
Sources include:
Please contact us for more information.
